Quantcast
Channel: Economics Job Market Rumors Forum: Econ Lounge - Recent Topics
Viewing all articles
Browse latest Browse all 12897

Economist on "Submitting higher after strong R&R - can I forward the referee reports?"

$
0
0

I received very positive reports on a paper at a good (but not top) field journal, and a strong signal from the editor that a (competently) revised version would likely be accepted.

I worry that I aimed too low with the paper. I still have several years before coming up for tenure, so I plan to submit the revised version to a top field journal.

My question is: can I forward on the referee reports from the previous journal, to speed up / facilitate the new editor's decision?


Viewing all articles
Browse latest Browse all 12897

Latest Images

Trending Articles



Latest Images